Archive for the Every Version of D&D Category

Every Version of D&D Part II: Men & Magic

Posted in Every Version of D&D, Projects, RPGs with tags , , on May 1, 2013 by Jeff Russell

menandmagiccoverart As promised, we’re beginning with the beginning – the Little Brown Books of the original white box.  Okay, yeah, yeah, you might call “the beginning” Chainmail or Braunstein or what have you, but this is the first thing released into the world as “Dungeons & Dragons”, though not yet as a “roleplaying game”.  I’m no James Malieszewski when it comes to the history of the game, but for this analysis, I’m more concerned with differences in the products as rules manuals that I can use now than I am in their history.  I will touch on it briefly (as well as I’m able) in order to speculate on what changes tell us about the play experiences the designers were trying to address.  But enough jibber jabber, let’s jump in.

Men & Magic

Here is something better!” First off, a word about formatting and graphic design (in the sense that Zak S. talks about it) – there isn’t any.  Well, that’s not true, there’s formatting of the sort some guys could do as hobbyists in 1974, and yes, there’s some charm to ‘slap it together yourself’ aesthetic, but it’s a terrible in-play reference.  Material isn’t very clearly grouped, there’s no index, and rather important concepts get a mention and that’s it.  I honestly think a lot of the reputation OD&D has for being “incomplete” or needing high levels of referee involvement and prep stems from the fact that it’s not formatted in a way where you can pick it up and use it as an instructional manual.  As I’ve mentioned before, I started out with the purist vision of playing actual OD&D, but after the first session of character creation and brief play, I made the switch to Swords & Wizardry Whitebox on account of its being easier to reference (and I actually have dreams of reformatting that in a more useful way, but it’s still loads easier to refer to in play than the LBBs). With these books, you have to read, re-read, internalize, interpret and otherwise work to make the text work for the game.  That’s okay, and there may even be some virtue in that, but overall I tend to come down on the position that RPG texts should facilitate learning the game and referencing the rules in play first, and being engaging and thought provoking works a distant second.  The engagement and thought provocation ought to come out in play rather than the rules.  Given how rarely RPGs acquire new players by someone picking up a book out of the blue and getting an impression of it from that book alone, I think that’s a fair set of priorities.  That tangent out of the way, let’s take a look at Men & Magic section by section, even if they are inadequate as organizational tools.

Foreword

There’s not much applicable to the rules here (as you’d expect), other than the emphasis on campaign play and the exhortation that these rules are intended for people with imagination. I like that.  As much as I admire a “scientific” approach to game design, where rules are crafted to attempt to guide players to the desired play experience, there’s a lot to be said for openly putting the onus on the players to use the toolkit provided.

Introduction, Scope, Preparation

So, despite my smack talking about OD&D’s value as an instructional manual, it does go into charmingly specific detail on recommended equipment: “Sheet Protectors (heaviest possible).”  It also gives a piece of advice that remains good to this day, around which I’ve built the entire Fellhold campaign – start small and build up detail as you go.  Other than that, it emphasizes the expectation that the referee will house rule like the devil, and the flexibility of the rules, from the prehistoric to the futuristic.  I like to think of this as acknowledging the then latent potential of roleplaying games as a form combined with some understandable boosterism for a fledgling product.

Characters, Abilities, and NPCs

What I find most interesting about the characters, abilities, and non-player characters sections is what they say about the play that produced them.  The character races that have become canonical are presented more in the sense of “hey, here’s the stuff we already figured out, but go ahead and make up something else if you want”.  Acquiring followers and armies, and their morale and loyalty scores get a lot of detail, showing the wargaming roots.  I like that abilities are “determined” rather than “created” – I think James Maliszewski hit on that on Grognardia, this notion that your character is randomly picked from all the possible characters in the world rather than crafted to your whim.    I’m still confused about the “use one stat for another at a 3 for 1 rate for experience purposes only”, but I don’t think I’m alone in that.

Equipment

Some of the prices here don’t show the same concern for medieval verisimilitude that later editions get to.  Though not listed here, it’s a running joke in my game that tents, as priced in Swords & Wizardry Whitebox, costs something like a year’s soldiering wages.  Great fun was had by me in describing the giants’ new loin cloths after they chased the party out of camp.

“Alternative” Combat System

Here we have the combat system that turned into D&D’s defining mechanic.  The tables are a little confusing, or rather the ways they try to save space by giving Magic Users and Clerics as relative values to Fighting Men.  Deep in my heart of hearts, I’m a THAC0 man myself, so I’m considering switching over, originalism be damned.  It’s interesting to me that AC only goes down to 2 and up to 9.  I’ll have to check out the Supplements to see when that was expanded.  The 10 to -10 spread is imminently logical, but it does divorce the idea that AC represents particular armor types.  That was probably inevitable, and possibly desirable, considering the diverse uses AC was already being put to to describe different monsters that are hard to hit for reasons other than wearing particular types of armor.

The saving throw matrix is also kind of terrible.

Spells

Level 1 spells have a lot of overlap between Magic Users and Clerics, but after that they start to diverge quite a bit.  Clerics get “Remove Curse” as a level 3 spell instead of level 4, and obviously have all the healing spells.  Otherwise, perhaps what’s most surprising about the spells is how little many of them have changed.  Effects and mechanics are remarkably consistent for many of them, and despite the profusion of spells available in later editions, most of the most used and iconic ones are right here.

Next up in the series will be “Monsters & Treasure”.

 

For rules, here is the method I used recently for filling out “adventure sites” as determined with the previous rules adapted from Welsh Piper (which generated too many adventure sites and too many large outposts for the vibe I was going for, but would have been good for creating a dense, interesting small map)

Adventure Site Generation

Take stuff from a good source like Dyson LogosHexenbracken or the Kraal, or the Tome of Adventure Design, or your favorite published setting material or:

01-60: Monster Lair

            – Roll Random Encounter Chart for Terrain type

61-70: Surface Ruins

            – Use outpost generation rules to determine size and type of ruins, then either roll random encounter chart for monsters there, add intelligent but dangerous inhabitants, or come up with something to make it worthwhile

71-80: Some Kind of Inhabited/Dangerous/Interesting Place besides an outpost

81-90: Small 1 Level Dungeon

            – Generate Randomly, Wing it, or Grab a map

91-00: Full Dungeon

            – Generate randomly, grab a map, or go whole hog and make it

Advertisements

Every Version of D&D Part I: Introduction

Posted in Every Version of D&D, Fellhold Campaign, Projects, RPGs with tags , , on April 24, 2013 by Jeff Russell

DDsmall

So, for some blog fodder, I’ve decided I’m going to take on the rather ambitious project of going through every version of D&D and comment on the rules.  To keep myself sane, I’ll be sticking to core books only.  I’m up in the air on OD&D if it will include the supplements or only the the original three LBB’s.  The idea is to hit up White Box, Holmes, Moldvay, Mentzer, Rules Cyclopedia, AD&D 1E, AD&D 2E, D&D 3/3.5, and 4E.  And I’ll probably have to get to Next if it’s out by the time I get through all of the other stuff.  Then, maybe I’ll hit up the retroclones for the sake of comparison.

Now, I’m sure somebody’s done something like this before, and I have read some “cover to cover” posts about specific editions, but my goal here is going to be to a) highlight the differences and think about why they are there, and b) identify those rules, tools, and ideas that are most useful to me for actual play, to aid me in kitbashing the Frankenstein’s monster of a “perfect version” for my campaign.   In large part, though, I just want to get to know the versions I’m not as personally familiar with (basically everything besides 2E and 4E). I expect it will take a while, but hopefully it will keep me gainfully blogging whenever I’m running short on ideas.  First up will be the original three LBB’s in the next post in the series.

Meanwhile, Fellhold Hex Stocking

(Using Welsh Piper’s Regional Hex Template, with 5 mile sub hexes and heavily cribbed from Lore.Keeper0’s Hex Crawl)

The lands around Fellhold are comparatively sparsely settled, so I’m going to modify the chances of an “outpost” (settlement type place) to be lower.  I’ll be running this for the regional hexes the players are currently traveling through first, and eventually flesh out the whole map.

For Each Regional Hex, determine the dominant terrain type (if you can’t tell, just use the center hex). In the case of dual terrain (like wooded hills) go down this list in this order for precedence. Roll the appropriate die for the number of outposts/settlements in the regional hex.  Then roll to determine size and inhabitants for each. Place as desired, or decide on a method to randomize placement:

Terrain Type

Number of Outposts

Size of Outposts

Inhabitants

Tundra/Glacier

1d2 – 1

Tiny (01-60)

Small (61-00)

Dwarves (01-10)

Men (11-00)

Mountains

1d3 – 1

Tiny (01-60)

Small (61-89)

Medium (90-00)

Trolls (01-40)

Trollkin (41-80)

Giants (81-90)

Dwarves (91-95)

Men (96-00)

Swamp/Fen

1d2 – 1

Tiny (01-70)

Small (71-00)

Trolls (01-20)

Trollkin (21-30)

Men (31-00)

Forest

1d3 – 1

Tiny (01-50)

Small (51-89)

Medium (90-00)

Trollkin (01-30)

Dwarves (31-35)

Men (36-00)

Hills

1d4 – 1

Tiny (01-50)

Small (51-80)

Medium (81-90)

Large (91-00)

Trollkin (01-30)

Dwarves (31-50)

Men (51-00)

Plains/Grassland

1d6 – 1

Tiny (01-50)

Small (51-70)

Medium (71-80)

Large (81-00)

Dwarves (01-20)

Men (21-00)

Outposts

  • Tiny: Individuals or very small groups, hermits, inns, mining/logging camps, homesteads
  • Small: Villages, trading posts, forts
  • Medium: Towns, keeps, market fairs
  • Large: Cities, castles, fortresses, tribal encampments

Next, roll the number of adventuring sites per regional hex by dominant terrain type:

Terrain Type

Number of Adventuring Sites

Tundra/Glacier

2D4

Mountains

2D6

Swamp/Fen

2D6

Forest

3D3

Hills

3D3

Plains/Grassland

2D4

Adventuring Sites

Adventuring sites are ruins, monster lairs, encounters, and so forth.  Detail as you like or use a cool random generator. Abulafia has lots of great stuff.